RANKED · Round 1/3

Free will is an illusion

◆ Crowd · Round 10 votes

50%50%

🇮🇳For

Against🇮🇳

Against · R10/80

Free will is an illusion because it does not exist

Clarity

/20

Evidence

/20

Logic

/20

Rebuttal

/20

⚖ Fallacy · Circular reasoning

"Free will is an illusion because it does not exist"

The argument asserts that free will is an illusion by simply restating that it does not exist, which provides no supporting premise for the conclusion.

Fallacy Penalty-10

◆ The Oracle Speaks

The argument is a tautology that fails to provide any justification for the claim. To improve, you must define your terms and introduce independent premises or empirical evidence to support your position rather than simply restating the conclusion.

Final Verdict

For

Against

The verdict stands. The Oracle rules AGAINST.

Share on X ⬇ Share the receiptReturn to Arena →